• 0 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 17th, 2026

help-circle

  • inline images are kind of trouble brewing for accessibility They’re not: the other image intensive platforms mentioned before handle them fine. The fediverse builds on the web, and web accessibility is quite mature.

    In particular, the alt attribute has existed since HTML 1.2 draft in 1993 (same year as initial release of HTML) when text-based web browsers (which still exist) were common. The web was accessible since the beginning.

    This reinforces the earlier point that web accessibility is not a limitation of capacity, but of will. The threadiverse is lagging.

    Yeah, okay, alt text can help, but not all users are going to write alt text

    That can be enforced & promoted in the environment. Platforms that do this better even in the fediverse were mentioned.

    (and I…don’t actually think that Threadiverse Markdown has a convention for adding inline image alt text at all, though I guess you could stick a manual caption beneath each image).

    It’s basic markdown.

    To add an image, add an exclamation mark (!), followed by alt text in brackets, and the path or URL to the image asset in parentheses. You can optionally add a title in quotation marks after the path or URL.

    AI image recognition AI recognition is unnecessary and faulty. The rest of the web doesn’t need it, and the other platforms mentioned before don’t rely on it.

    As WebAIM states

    Although technology is getting better at recognizing what an image depicts, algorithms alone cannot understand what an image means within the context of the overall page. A maple leaf might represent Canada, or it might just illustrate the leaf of a tree. Web page authors must provide alternative text that represents the content and function of their images.

    a text alternative is a substitute that conveys equivalent purpose in context. Unless AI reads an author’s mind, it will miss contextual meaning & intent. It will also garble text, misinterpret non-text content, sequence complex content wrong.

    The alt attribute in particular is typically accurate & equivalent, succinct, not redundant. Complex images get a succinct alt attribute and an adjacent text alternative or link to text alternative.

    Of course, an image of text doesn’t need to be an image at all. Culture & enforcement could discourage that anti-pattern.

    For the threadiverse, the top issue is images lacking text alternative. However, text alternatives apply to any non-text content[1] and web accessibility encompasses more than that, which the platform mostly addresses.


    1. the formal guideline:

      Provide text alternatives for any non-text content so that it can be changed into other forms people need, such as large print, braille, speech, symbols or simpler language.

      ↩︎








  • For the record, I’m not making a free speech absolutist argument.

    That’s a really strange disclaimer over a fundamental right akin to

    I’m not a self-determination absolutist

    I’m not a due-process-of-law absolutist

    I’m not a freedom-of-movement absolutist

    I’m not a freedom-of-conscience absolutist

    I’m not a warranted-search-and-seizure absolutist

    Absolutism here isn’t mentioned to disclaim protection of illegal speech, because that’s already unprotected, and no one here would dispute that. In this context, absolutism disclaims protection of unpopular speech people here would denounce, so it disclaims freedom of speech entirely.

    This denies the presumption of a fundamental right as protected, which is entirely backward. Fundamental rights are presumed protected, whereas attempts to restrict or challenge them need strict scrutiny. The less common disclaimer

    I’m not a censorship absolutist

    is an asymmetry revealing a copout.

    As for regulation, it’s a private device people are free to denounce, customize, or reject for a competitor. People have the liberty to produce & choose censored junk. An open society doesn’t restrict such choices when it can leverage fundamental rights[1] to denounce, criticize, and challenge.


    1. this community seems to cower from defending ↩︎


  • So youre saying the actual cops would have responded to Jane does gang rape instead of the “cops, but like we work for Cornell first and ignore a gang rape victim telling us she was gang raped when we write up the summation doc for the DA” cops? Ithaca cops that would have arrested the rapists, and then told the school, who could have then done their own academic action regardless of the frat or not?

    That is by no means certain. Cops employed by government rather than a private or unelected employer (the legality of which is completely bizarre in a liberal democracy) have a horrible record of abuse despite their theoretical accountability to the public. The DA wasn’t employed by the university, and they went only by Jane Doe’s signed statement to conclude her allegations contradicted elements necessary to charge for rape as defined in state law. The statement she said she was very confident about was produced in an interview led by a campus police investigator alongside a Title IX investigator, a victim advocate, and Jane Doe’s adviser. Government police would have produced a similar statement, except the interview would have lacked university employees, especially the Title IX investigator.

    Title IX is an anti-discrimination law that protects students’ equal access to educational opportunities regardless of sex. As long as the institution’s programs & activities don’t sexually discriminate or deny equal access, and a claim doesn’t allege the contrary, such claims lack Title IX interests. School conduct code violations unrelated to Title IX lack legal obligations beyond terms of contract.

    Private conduct (of mostly adults) outside the school environment that doesn’t affect it lacks Title IX interests, and it would make total sense for schools to focus more narrowly on legal obligations instead of assuming responsibility beyond that of independent individuals and organizations responsible for their own conduct.

    Ironically, the school so far has imposed more adverse action on the accused than have our public institutions, which have imposed none. If the DA’s initial determination is correct, the state may end up imposing nothing for an accusation negated by alleged facts.

    Though the results in practice may be worse, I still think public police are preferable to non-public, because they lack conflict of interest to an unelected employer, and they could be held accountable to the public with sufficient public will and reform.




  • lmmarsano@fedinsfw.apptoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.world•Game misconduct
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    21 days ago

    The paradox of tolerance is literally just about too much tolerance of the intolerant causing issues in society.

    It’s literally not.
    Repeating reductive shit they say on social media doesn’t make it true.
    Your ignorance of the source material is telling.

    There’s a Wikipedia article quoting part of it

    [Less well known is the paradox of tolerance: Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.—In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise.] But we should claim the right to suppress them [intolerant ideologies] if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols.

    explaining the various takes on it.
    It comes from a book called The Open Society and Its Enemies about what I stated.

    The type of intolerance the quote refers to is the kind that uses force and refuses debate.
    They even explicitly reject that we should in general “suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies” as long as rational argument & public opinion still govern public choice.

    background: book promotes intellectual freedom

    The book’s thesis is that an open society (ie, liberalism) has stronger merits than the newer, trendier totalitarian political theories of the day predicated on teleological historicism.
    They approached this from their background in philosophy of science (emphasizing enterprises controlled by skepticism and free inquiry) to argue that liberal democracies are not inevitably doomed by totalitarian systems of power, because liberal institutions have an overlooked strength

    Only democracy allows an institutional framework that permits reform without violence, and so the use of reason in political matters

    and to keep totalitarian systems like fascism or communism at bay, we need to sustain institutions that allow for open inquiry and grant all citizens extensive rights against their governments.

    Even with the best rulers, unchecked power is likely to err and cause unbound damage.
    Instead of focusing only on selecting the best rulers, a better system of government might determine

    How can we so organize political institutions that bad or incompetent rulers can be prevented from doing too much damage?

    They resolved that such a system should include strict limits on the power of the state and a special emphasis on intellectual freedom.

    They were absolutely arguing in favor of more open discourse & deliberation, not force, to reform government without violence and restrict its potential damage.
    That means tolerating opinions we disagree with from people who don’t try to impose them with force.

    Unsurprisingly, you shouldn’t expect philosophers who emphasize free, open inquiry and rational argument as crucial to an open society to defend forcible suppression of tolerant disagreements in it.
    Colloquial intolerance isn’t the stricter intolerance they refer to.
    We can observe intolerance of actual intolerance as posed in that book in action: we do live in a society roughly following the system that book was defending, assault (including that motivated by violent extremism) is a crime, and our society doesn’t tolerate it pretty much as I stated before.

    Social media dumbasses butchered the idea into bullshit pop philosophy, and you aren’t winning any arguments by regurgitating shit that’s flat out wrong unless that argument is “How dumb is social media? Very.”


  • lmmarsano@fedinsfw.apptoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.world•Game misconduct
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    21 days ago

    Because you’re absolutely wrong about the paradox of tolerance?
    Your butchered social media interpretation of it is not at all what the philosophers who articulated the idea meant by it or concluded from it.

    1. It’s a paradox, not a conclusion, and not your conclusion.
    2. They were arguing about the merits of liberal governments over the unchecked power of totalitarian systems.
      Particularly, they called out the overlooked merits of intellectual freedom and political institutions structured to limit potential damage of government power through rational debate and deliberative, competitive decision-making.
    3. The meaning of intolerant in philosophy is more technical than merely an opinion that disagrees with other ways: it requires literally prohibiting other ways by unjustified force.

    Accordingly, someone who is not imposing their opinion on society with force is tolerant.
    Contrary to your position, they would argue that beating a tolerant person over an opinion is a case of intolerance.
    Such an appeal to force has no place in open society, and an open society is justified to not tolerate it.

    To resolve your paradox, a tolerant, open society would be justified to drop Unfiltered Mama’s son into juvie.


  • Anytime someone brings up paradox of intolerance in the fediverse, the chance is very high they’re completely wrong about it and are regurgitating shit they read from some dumbass on social media.

    1. The paradox of intolerance is a paradox, not a conclusion.
    2. The reductive conclusion social media dumbasses insinuate by invoking it is entirely wrong according to the philosopher who articulated the paradox.
    3. Intolerant carries a more technical meaning in philosophy (at least to that philosopher) than a mere disagreement with other ways: it includes the element of imposing (by unjustified force) on society to literally prohibit other ways. People who do not force us to comply with their position are tolerant.

    From the article (you didn’t read or understand) quoting Karl Popper (extended with the rest of the passage)

    [Less well known is the paradox of tolerance: Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.—In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise.] But we should claim the right to suppress them [intolerant ideologies] if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols.

    The type of intolerance they refer to is the kind that uses force and refuses debate. They even explicitly reject that we should in general “suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies” as long as rational argument & public opinion still govern public choice.

    background: book promotes intellectual freedom

    The quote comes from a footnote in the book The Open Society and Its Enemies, whose thesis is that an open society (ie, liberalism) has stronger merits than the newer, trendier totalitarian political theories of the day predicated on teleological historicism. They approached this from their background in philosophy of science (emphasizing enterprises controlled by skepticism and free inquiry) to argue that liberal democracies are not inevitably doomed by totalitarian systems of power, because liberal institutions have an overlooked strength

    Only democracy allows an institutional framework that permits reform without violence, and so the use of reason in political matters

    and to keep totalitarian systems like fascism or communism at bay, we need to sustain institutions that allow for open inquiry and grant all citizens extensive rights against their governments.

    Even with the best rulers, unchecked power is likely to err and cause unbound damage. Instead of focusing only on selecting the best rulers, a better system of government might determine

    How can we so organize political institutions that bad or incompetent rulers can be prevented from doing too much damage?

    They resolved that such a system should include strict limits on the power of the state and a special emphasis on intellectual freedom.

    They were absolutely arguing in favor of more open discourse & deliberation, not less of it, to reform government without violence and restrict its potential damage. That means tolerating opinions we disagree with from people who don’t try to impose them with force.

    Their discussion on public policy has no bearing on the democratic consequences accepting code that “solves the problem” from people we disagree with. It’s pretty much accepting charity and doesn’t imply you promote or agree with their views at all. Philosophers generally scoff at purity policing bullshit and genetic fallacies, especially those who emphasize free, open inquiry and rational argument as crucial to an open society.



  • Don’t you think it’s fucked, though, in terms of accountability & integrity of government authority? Some people might assume police authority belongs exclusively to the government and ultimately answers to the public through elected officials, yet here we have unelected private employers setting their conditions of employment and directing policy with no inherent duty to the public. That scheme seems at odds with basic premises of liberal democratic governance. Private employment of police officers isn’t necessary to assign public officers to beats at campuses with specialized policies.

    Law enforcement is bad enough when accountable to the public. Despite the results, severing that accountability & governance is in principle unsound.



  • Failing to review transcripts is substandard practice: serious fault in the DA there. However, unless significant allegations in the transcript are absent from the statement, it’s unlikely to resolve the statement’s contradiction of a crime.

    A confident claim is not a conclusive legal determination drawn from alleged facts. According to the reported transcript, she was confident about the statement, too:

    On the second day of the interview, Jane Doe reviewed the revised six-page statement. The transcript shows her adviser asked if she wanted her and another adviser to review the statement.

    Before signing, the transcript shows Jane Doe said, “I’m very confident about this.”

    When the only allegation recommending a criminal charge alleges facts that not only fail to support that conclusion but negate key statutory elements of the crime, that eliminates every prosecutable theory and legal basis for an investigation. Such a contradiction is not resolvable through further investigation. At least some plausible basis for a crime needs to be articulated for an investigation to justifiably proceed.

    The DA gave the complainant notice of his determination and an opportunity to review it together. That was another chance to raise any allegations the DA could have missed & explain how they arrived to their conclusion when alleged facts reviewed so far didn’t support it. The complainant apparently waived the opportunity.

    The “multiple things indicating lack of consent” are worse than you wrote, yet they don’t satisfy the element of the crime. A feeling lacking clear expression is not a fact supporting the legal standard; she had the liberty to reject, exercised it, and was met with compliance

    According to the statement, each time Jane Doe asked to stop the sexual conduct, the sexual conduct stopped.

    Shutting down events and distasteful language in snapchat obviously don’t qualify.

    Much that you mention or that comes up in these stories is already in the statement, too. Some allegation that actually meets the legal standards is needed.