just a random stranger

codeberg: https://codeberg.org/asudox

aspe:keyoxide.org:D63IYCGSU4XXB5JSCBBHXXFEHQ

  • 2 Posts
  • 27 Comments
Joined 12 days ago
cake
Cake day: January 18th, 2025

help-circle
  • No, of course I don’t. I am not as paranoid as Richard Stallman, but I am also not as pronoid as the average human to just use proprietary software when there are similarly functioning open source software. With open source software, you can inspect the code and compile the code that you inspected. This is not true for something like iOS.

    And of course, FOSS malware also exists (for example the recent xz data compression program). But guess what? You can find if it is really malware or not because you ultimately can inspect the code and compile the code you inspected. That is also why the malware in xz was found out. Who knows what there is in closed source software you can’t inspect the code of. Do you perhaps believe in security through obscurity?

    Using open source software is always an advantage. Praise for privacy software should be earned through the ability to verify them, and not granted by default.


  • I don’t know about you but if I don’t know what a program that I can’t inspect the code of does, I’ll just assume the worst case scenario. I can’t prove it but you also can’t prove that it isn’t doing something shady, can you? So what if I am using Private Relay? Apple will know what websites I visit or what I do with my phone as long as I use their proprietary operating system and who knows who they’ll give it to. And with this, I am saying it again: Apple’s operating systems are no exception to this rule.



  • You do have a good point. However, I can’t consider a proprietary operating system like iOS truly private. It may be secure (certainly more so than stock Android and some random custom Android based ones) but if I can’t be sure that my operating system isn’t spying on me, then security alone doesn’t matter much for me tbh. Apple’s operating systems are no exception to this.

    So, in a ranking that considers both security AND privacy, iOS being the second one is questionable. However, if the ranking is based solely on security, then I have no issue with it.