Honestly, I’m going to go with spiders. I love spiders, and the fact that I can have an army of Hobos, Fiddlebacks (Brown Recluse), Redbacks, Mouse, and Funnelwebs, that people are already naturally are terrified of but also regularly prey on other insects? Yes please! Plus, it would mean all the jumpers would be my buddies! Precious little fluffy babies<3
A close second is wasps, but that’s only because wasps species make up 1/3 of all insect species out there.
So horror movies are already pretty tough, but I have to say, Annabelle Creations is definitely better than the original (if you’re only counting Annabelle, and not the whole Conjuring/Annabelle universe deal).