• 0 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • You also get the same issue with trans men. We a had a local case where a trans man was convicted of a crime, and the local authorities decided to send him to a male prison, respecting his self-identification. He proceeded to immediatly challenge this through the courts for obvious reasons.

    In this situation, it’s impossible to escape the drawbacks of your biology so long as prisons assume a dichotomy. And the vast majority of the population considers any criminal to be subhuman anyway, so asking them to acommodate a sub-percentage of what is already a tiny 0.1% of the population is impossible. They would sooner vote to just execute them to save themselves the hassle and expense.





  • In the Chinese Room scenario, cards with Chinese written on them are inserted into a box.

    Inside there is a man who doesn’t understand Chinese but has a lookup list of which symbols to write as a response to every possible sentence you can write on the inserted card.

    For anyone observing from outside the box it looks as if whatever is in the box is fluent in Chinese and can hold a conversation. But the man inside does not understand anything about Chinese.

    This is used as an analogy to explain that machines, very much like the man in the box, do not actually understand the data they are fed, nor the data they output, no matter how human the response might seem.

    It was an argument against the Turing test, which is about whether machines showing behaviour indistinguishable from a human is a sign that they can think.

    The Chinese Room argument is that they must also show understanding of the data itself, rather than just human-like responses, to say that they think.