The power of context is truly remarkable. Max Fosh convinces coffee nerds that the worst coffee possible, is actually nice.
I am quite annoyed by this, since I know from experience how big the difference is between expensive and cheap coffee.
I’m guessing it was serving it cold that made the trick plausible. Or is it true what normies think of coffee people? That coffee is just coffee, it’s not that deep. I disagree personally.


The whole specialty coffee world is such a niche market that it is, at least in my opinion, vastly occupied by enthusiasts that work in this field not because they want to make money but because they are passionate about coffee. They also usually try to use fair(er) supply chains and (try to?!) minimize unequal exchange. Profit margins are much smaller in specialty coffee because of this.
The bigger industrial roasters work by other incentives. I wouldn’t say that they fuck it up because of incompetence though. They usually use lower quality coffee in the first place and then roast them darker because their main goal is consistency rather than exaggeration of origin characteristics. They then use manipulative marketing to hide all the shitty stuff they have to do to get to the cheaper and more consistent end product (essentially pretending they’d do all the stuff the specialty coffee roasters actually do).
But in general i’ll have to admit that coffee drinking the way we in the global north do is very unsustainable. I usually try to buy raw beans directly, roast them myself and drink less but better coffee, rather than a lot. I am very passionate about coffee but i once estimated the amount of coffee plants i would personally need to sustain my own coffee consumption and let’s just say i’d need a pretty big garden …
I agree that the fuckery is not incompetence. It’s profit motive wrapped in marketing.
I’ve considered buying green beans and doing my own roasting if it could be done without an expensive machine. More to have fun experimenting than to become good at it because I’ve seen the science behind roasting and don’t feel I have the knowledge to do it well. Still, experimenting would be fun.
I don’t have direct knowledge, but my guess would be that farmers would be ecstatic about your (and my) substantial coffee consumption if they received a fair price for their beans. I’d think fairness would further be increased if more people buy coffee that is not only grown in places like Panamá, Ethiopia, Colombia, etc, but roasted there as well. But that’s not possible where everywhere, so roasting your own is a wonderful idea. Also sounds like fun.