“Wins”, really? That’s a disgusting way of putting it. He’s compensated for time spent in prison, but the time will be forever lost.
Not to mention that, while objectively a lot of money to most people, $4m is a piss-poor compensation for 18 years of your life!
That is 26$/h spent in prison. Take that for what you will, but it’s hard for me to define how to compensate someone fairly for wrongful imprisonment. Money comes, money goes, but time only passes. It won’t come back.
Yeah, $26/h is a good rate for work wages, but not for losing a major chunk of your life and the resulting trauma from it. Contrary to some “tough guy” portrayals in fiction, your psyche and relationship with society WILL be forever fractured from being caged for so long , no matter how you were before.
I wouldn’t wish that on GUILTY prisoners, let alone someone who was wrongfully convicted like in this case.
Yeah it really is hard to quantify. Even just taking into account the financial aspect if he was working during that time he would have been developing skills and becoming worth more to employ as well. He’s effectively 18 years behind career and skills wise where he could have been.
EDIT: shit, it’s even worse than that.
“Alan was 24 when he was arrested. He is now 61.”
It also said he had an intellectual disability. I don’t know how severe it is but being a convicted murderer for most of your life would Rob you of so many opportunities. Fucking hell.
I was confused at first because 61 - 24 isn’t 18, but then realized he did have a length of time out on parole before he was sent back for violating parole.
It works out about $15 US or £12 or €14 p.h.
deleted by creator
It’s not even 2.4 million USD. That’s not nearly enough.
Courts have a really hard time admitting to any wrongdoing. When someone innocent gets released, they see it as a loss, because they don’t care about justice. They decided this man was guilty for whatever reason, and a win for them would have been to keep him imprisoned. His innocence is irrelevant to their decision.
So that’s about 2.95M USD or 2.7M EUR, I wouldn’t go to prison for 18 years for that amount of money that’s for sure.
Went to prison at 24 and got his 4m nzd payout at 61. Fuuuck that what a failure of the justice system.
Not only was he wrongfully convicted, but the true killer apparently went free?
It should be 1mil per year, minimum.
10 times that at least. That’s pennies compared to the amnount he lost
On one hand, it’s not nearly enough. Nobody would voluntarily give away that much of their life for that much money, which is the standard they should use. OTOH, I’m surprised he got anything at all, because I’ve never heard of a government that would voluntarily admit any kind of liability for wrongful convictions.
People are giving away that much of their life for much less money all the time. That’s literally what working is.
Prison isn’t like work. Sure there’s a lot to not like about work but comparing it to prison is a step too far
Do you spend 24 hours a day at work?
I just did the math and if I spent the next 18 years at my current job with my current salary I’d earn about 500.000 moneys. Well, shit.
If he was imprisoned with 24 and is now 61 he either was 37 years in prison or fought 19 years for compensation.
Mr Hall was released on parole in 1994 only to be sent back to jail in 2012
Yeah too little
He can hardly buy a house with that
