Because this it’s trivial to write it in a way that won’t cause this confusion and yet every 3 months or so someone posts another one of these gotcha no context given equations and we as the internet have this same discussion again and again. It’s bait…
Do you remember how this reply thread started? I literally fixed the equation so that it would be less confusing to people, I couldn’t do that if I didn’t know what order it was meant to go in…
I’m just not assuming that people are stupid because they got tripped up by something designed to trip them up.
It’s writing like this with math, you can find the sentence structure, but it makes it a puzzle people will mess up unnecessarily
But you didn’t “Fix” the equation, because it wasn’t “broken.” You just rearranged it so that it made more sense to you, yourself, personally. It already made sense to other people who’ve learned the proper order of operations. Your metaphor fails here because unlike the signs you posted above, this equation is perfectly understandable in either form.
I’m sorry my friend, math is not “mean.” You cannot use math to oppress people.
Those sentence are also perfectly understandable, once you’ve understood the order of the words, but they’re written in such away that you have to think about it.
If there are multiple ways to do things and one is more accessible to most people with less effort that isn’t the objectively right way but it is better.
It’s obviously not just myself as posting out of order math problems are a constant source of online engagement.
Those sentence are also perfectly understandable, once you’ve understood the order of the words, but they’re written in such away that you have to think about it.
No, they aren’t. Read the way they’re written, as in left to right, none of those sentances make sense. They do not make sense because it disobeys the rules of grammar.
But the math equation 2+5(8-5)=17 makes perfect sense. Writing it like (8+5)5+2 =17 also makes perfect sense, but writing it this way does not somehow enable it to make “more” sense than the first way. It does not, because both of those equations are the exact same thing. It’s called “the law of equivalence,” i.e. 2+5=5+2. It’s just two ways of writing the exact same thing. You cannot do this with grammar. “The Horse eats the grass” =/= “The grass eats the Horse.” You cannot just rearrange the words in a sentance and get the same meaning the same way you can rearrange the elements in an equation.
It’s not “less effort” to read it one way or the other, because both of those equations are exactly the same. It only makes “more” sense to YOU, yourself, personally. But to everyone else who learned the oder of operations it makes no difference which way it’s written.
It’s obviously not just myself as posting out of order math problems are a constant source of online engagement.
Like I said in the begining, people are fucking stupid.
Because this it’s trivial to write it in a way that won’t cause this confusion and yet every 3 months or so someone posts another one of these gotcha no context given equations and we as the internet have this same discussion again and again. It’s bait…
Well, it’s causing YOU confusion yes. But to anyone who remembers the order of operation it’s not confusing at all.
Do you remember how this reply thread started? I literally fixed the equation so that it would be less confusing to people, I couldn’t do that if I didn’t know what order it was meant to go in…
I’m just not assuming that people are stupid because they got tripped up by something designed to trip them up.
It’s writing like this with math, you can find the sentence structure, but it makes it a puzzle people will mess up unnecessarily
But you didn’t “Fix” the equation, because it wasn’t “broken.” You just rearranged it so that it made more sense to you, yourself, personally. It already made sense to other people who’ve learned the proper order of operations. Your metaphor fails here because unlike the signs you posted above, this equation is perfectly understandable in either form.
I’m sorry my friend, math is not “mean.” You cannot use math to oppress people.
Those sentence are also perfectly understandable, once you’ve understood the order of the words, but they’re written in such away that you have to think about it.
If there are multiple ways to do things and one is more accessible to most people with less effort that isn’t the objectively right way but it is better.
It’s obviously not just myself as posting out of order math problems are a constant source of online engagement.
No, they aren’t. Read the way they’re written, as in left to right, none of those sentances make sense. They do not make sense because it disobeys the rules of grammar.
But the math equation 2+5(8-5)=17 makes perfect sense. Writing it like (8+5)5+2 =17 also makes perfect sense, but writing it this way does not somehow enable it to make “more” sense than the first way. It does not, because both of those equations are the exact same thing. It’s called “the law of equivalence,” i.e. 2+5=5+2. It’s just two ways of writing the exact same thing. You cannot do this with grammar. “The Horse eats the grass” =/= “The grass eats the Horse.” You cannot just rearrange the words in a sentance and get the same meaning the same way you can rearrange the elements in an equation.
It’s not “less effort” to read it one way or the other, because both of those equations are exactly the same. It only makes “more” sense to YOU, yourself, personally. But to everyone else who learned the oder of operations it makes no difference which way it’s written.
Like I said in the begining, people are fucking stupid.